Too Good to Be True by Prajakta Koli

Too Good to Be True by Prajakta Koli: The Sweet and Witty Romance Novel Every Book Lover Needs to Read

About the Book

Too Good to Be True is a sparkling, witty, and genuinely charming debut novel that brings the magic of romance fiction to real life. Avani’s favourite thing to do is bury her nose in romance novels, but life cannot be trusted to make those stories real. Until the day a man walks into the bookstore where she works, and he seems straight out of the pages of her favourite love stories. This book is warm, funny, and impossible to put down.

From the Back Cover

Aman is hot, successful, and seems to know what Avani is going to say before she has said it. He just cannot get enough of her. In short, he is perfect. Then why is Avani losing her mind, ignoring the advice of her best friends, and trying to convince herself that he is just too good to be true? Sometimes the love story you have been waiting for is standing right in front of you. The only question is whether you will let yourself believe it.

About the Author

Prajakta Koli, also known as MostlySane, is one of India’s most influential digital creators, actors, and storytellers, with over 18 million followers across social media platforms. In 2025, she was the only Indian on the TIME100 Creators list, which recognized her impact on culture and storytelling worldwide. Too Good to Be True is her debut novel, which became a national number one bestseller on release.

Who Is This Book For?

This book is a perfect pick for fans of light, feel-good contemporary romance who want a story that is funny, relatable, and genuinely heartwarming. Readers who enjoy witty banter, emotional tug-of-wars, and Gen Z-friendly storytelling will feel right at home in this fast-paced, charming debut. It is also a wonderful read for anyone who already loves Prajakta’s content and wants to experience her storytelling in a brand new way.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1: Is Too Good to Be True a good romance novel for first-time readers?
Yes, it is one of the best choices for first-time romance readers. The story is easy to follow, fast-paced, and packed with humor and heart. Many readers have finished it in a single day. If you are new to romance fiction or just want something light and enjoyable, this book is a great place to start.

Q2: Is Too Good to Be True by Prajakta Koli suitable for teenagers?
Yes, the book is suitable for readers aged 16 and above. The romance is sweet and low-key, with less emphasis on physical intimacy and more focus on emotional connection, friendship, and family. It is a clean, wholesome love story that parents and teens can both feel comfortable with.

Q3: What kind of romance story is Too Good to Be True? Is it a slow-burn?
It follows the popular will-they-won’t-they format, which means the romantic tension builds throughout the story as both characters try to figure out their feelings. The tone is chatty, casual, and filled with witty banter and emotional moments, making it a fun and engaging read for anyone who loves romantic tension done with a light touch.

Q4: Has Too Good to Be True won any awards?
Yes, Too Good to Be True won the Amazon India Popular Choice Debut Book 2025 Award, making it one of the most recognized debut romance novels from an Indian author in recent years. It also hit the national number one bestseller list on the day of its release, which says everything about how much readers have connected with it.